Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Clever Pseudonym's avatar

My wife is a successful novelist and we are usually knee-deep in galleys so I have some ideas here: the publishing business is so very female (the few men are mostly gay) and so uniformly devoted to Social Justice in all ways that any man who does not come with the NYT/NPR seal of approval or who does not check any of the major victim-identity categories will either be rejected outright or will give up before even trying to navigate the political minefield—we have 2 friends who are previously published white-male novelists who were told in so many words to not even bother submitting a manuscript, they would not be considered; also, we know a few Latino or Asian guys who are half-white or who were raised in almost entirely upscale white worlds who gained literary success by mastering the victim game and positioning themselves as both victims of white oppression and allies of the Soc Just cause, thus opening all doors for books and awards; and probably most importantly, the publishing business (much like all liberal culture) has become so blinkered, so neurotic and sclerotic, that they might be the last people to know where are the new good books—they have very little interest in literature, but an intense need to be constantly broadcasting the proper political opinions.

Samizdat is the way to go, and in 10 or so years we'll learn about the real best books of say 2020-2024 once they get reissued or made into movies.

Expand full comment
Michael's avatar

So half the fiction by white male authors is about suitably woke subjects anyway.

Expand full comment
43 more comments...

No posts