Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Erik's avatar

I've wondered aloud in recent discussions with friends, if historically the best places to be for the average person, was within an empire, after the main conquest phase, but before the decline. I don't have the historical knowledge, nor desire for research to defend this idea on the facts. It just seems to me with empire you remove the constant threat of the ethnic group next door deciding to ride in and take your stuff and rape your women. You get the benefits of secure trade with far flung lands. The central government has the time and finances to do public works projects.

The only downside I can think of is that it offends the primitive instinct to want to think of one's own group as being in charge. It isn't good for the self esteem to think some other group of winners better than you. Yet often the better people in your own group will get with the imperial program and enjoy the benefits.

I suppose the anti-colonial narrative would involve the empire stealing resources from the colonized. Does that outright happen often in history? I know that in some cases the colonized (India, America) say the empire sets up rules around manufacturing unfairly but I don't know how common this has been. I sense a lot of the more recent colonies wouldn't have done much exploiting of their natural resources without the Imperials.

Expand full comment
Bob Thebuilder's avatar

FWIW, the British really did leave a strong legacy of effective administration in their colonies. I've been watching a lot of Indian movies on Netflix and Amazon prime lately and the Indians seem openly to miss the British because they were a lot less corruptible than the current locals. There are no instances in historical movies about colonial rule where a British administrator was venal or corrupt, whereas instances of corruption by Indian officials and policemen arise on a daily basis in most movies about contemporary Indian life. It's a tribute to Singapore's success and self-confidence that they are willing to acknowledge that legacy openly.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts