Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Shawn Buell's avatar

Just as there are more male morons and male geniuses - the male distribution is spread out further into the tails.

Is it possible that the effects of testosterone drive outliers further in the male population?

Expand full comment
SlowlyReading's avatar

Hypothesis: The more that nurture/culture is improved through relentless competition and the spread of 'best practices' in nurture, the more the results will reflect nature rather than nurture.

Men are more devoted to sports in general, so most of the best male athletes end up using the best possible nurture to max out their natural potential, and their results are more reflective of their nature.

Women are more lackadaisical about sports, so a lot of the women with the best natural gifts don't end up using the best possible nurture to compete at 100% of their natural potential, and their results are more reflective of their nurture.

It's the sex-based opposite of the situation with grades and testing in school. In school, conscientious women mostly study hard, and their test results ought to reflect their natural gifts more perfectly, while a lot of men underuse their gifts, so their results reflect more of their nurture.

Expand full comment
21 more comments...

No posts